Skip to content Sitemap

Excellence in Property Management

Our personalized service, local expertise and property management experience will make finding your next rental home easy!

Find Your Home
At First Story Property Management, LLC, our focus is on exceptional management of homes, condos, and townhomes in Tallahassee, Florida. First Story Property Management is different, and we know it; our owners and residents tell us this all the time. They recognize our commitment to the relationships we have built with and between both owners and residents.

“First Story Property Management is a great company, Shanna and Brianne are awesome!!”
– Anna H. resident

Current & Future Residents

If you are searching for a new rental home, we have a top-notch inventory of houses, condos, and townhomes for lease. We take the time to get to know you – to understand your individual needs and work with you to find the right home in the perfect location. You can view our availability in real-time, find the perfect home, apply to rent with us and sign your lease ALL online.

When you rent from us, you can be assured of our attention to detail, efficiency and pride in service. Our residents experience the peace-of-mind that comes from a professionally managed rental home. We would love to have you as a resident in one of our properties.

Owners & Investors

If you own a residential investment home and are looking for professional management, look no further! We partner with you to provide complete management services, including marketing, tenant screening, leasing, maintenance, and accounting. Our reputation is the best in the area – just ask our current clients.

“Great team, very responsive and professional….they really get things done. Thank you Shanna and Brianne!”
– Rebecca S. owner